Back to All Posts
Insights

The Pirate's Secret: How a Lost Recipe Became Puerto Rico's Pride

From 19th-century pirate morale boosters to Eurovision hits, the piña colada's journey is more legendary than you'd expect!

SpinQuizr Team

August 25, 20252 min read
The Pirate's Secret: How a Lost Recipe Became Puerto Rico's Pride
Photo by Deeliver on Unsplash

The Legendary Tale of Liquid Paradise

Ever wondered how a simple mix ofrum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice became one of the world's most beloved cocktails? The piña colada's story is more thrilling than any treasure hunt! The name literally means "strained pineapple" in Spanish, but its origins are steeped in Caribbean legend and friendly rivalry.

From Pirate Ships to Five-Star Hotels

Legend has it that19th-century Puerto Rican pirate Roberto Cofresí created this tropical elixir to boost his crew's morale. When he died in 1825, the recipe supposedly died with him – talk about taking secrets to Davy Jones' locker! But like any good story, this one has multiple plot twists.

Fast-forward to the 1950s, whenthree different people claimed to have "invented" the modern piña colada. The Caribe Hilton Hotel says bartender Ramón "Monchito" Marrero perfected it in 1954, while Spaniard Ricardo García claims he beat him by a year. Meanwhile, Barrachina restaurant insists their Don Ramón Portas Mingot created it in 1963. Who's telling the truth? Perhaps that's a mystery better left to chance – or a spinning wheel!

More Than Just a Drink – It's Culture in a Glass

In 1978, Puerto Rico made it official by declaring the piña colada theirnational cocktail. The drink gained worldwide fame thanks to Rupert Holmes' 1979 hit song "Escape (The Piña Colada Song)," and recently got another boost from Finnish rapper Käärijä's Eurovision entry "Cha Cha Cha." From pirates to pop culture – now that's range!

Spin Your Way to Tropical Knowledge

Whether you prefer yours blended smooth or shaken with ice, one thing's certain: the piña colada represents the beautiful randomness of culinary evolution. Ready to test your tropical cocktail knowledge?Try our piña colada-themed quiz on SpinQuizr and see if you can separate the coconut cream from the myths!

Ready to Play?

Enjoyed this post? Click the button below to start a pre-configured quiz session based on this topic right now!

Quiz Preview:

20 questions

8 players: Captain Coconut, Pineapple Pete, Tropical Tina, Rum Runner Ray, Island Isabella, Bartender Bob, Caribbean Carlos, Paradise Patty